How ShoppTrust decides
Most checkers only tell you whether a site is known to be bad. Fake shops appear every few minutes and vanish within weeks, so most are on no list. ShoppTrust instead asks a positive question: can we verify who runs this shop?
The six results
We recommend buying from, and dealing with, only shops rated Trusted. Every other result - including "Known, with some issues" - is not a recommendation to buy.
- Trusted
- All of: the site names a registered, active company that we found in an official register (UK Companies House, the Israeli Corporations Authority, or an EU VAT number confirmed by the EU's VIES register) and whose name appears on the site; the domain has at least a year of history; the shop has contact details and terms or returns information; it uses HTTPS; and no warning sign was found. Where a register confirms a VAT number but does not disclose its holder (e.g. Germany), the number counts only on a domain with three or more years of unbroken history. An Israeli company found only by the legal name the site shows (no company number) also counts only on a domain with three or more years of unbroken history.
- Established shops: on a domain with three or more years of unbroken history, an inconsistency with a register (for example a lapsed VAT number, or a legal entity named differently from the brand) prevents a Trusted verdict but is not treated as evidence of fraud.
- Known, with some issues
- A business we know and verified - its identity, a year or more of history and a readable shop - but with issues that keep it from Trusted: it does not say who runs it, customers rate its service poorly, it sells risky products (cheap licence keys, social-media followers), or it can only be reached by a free e-mail address. Each issue is listed on the report with its evidence. It is not a warning that the shop is a scam - but we don't recommend buying from it or doing business with it because of these issues: we recommend buying only from shops rated Trusted.
- Not enough evidence
- Nothing bad was found, but not enough could be verified. This is not a safety rating: many new or small genuine shops are here, and so are fake shops that have not shown any warning sign yet. The report says which of three situations it is: Looks normal so far (most checks passed; only the proof, usually who runs it, is missing), Several checks failed (under 75% of the checks passed - be careful), or Couldn't be checked (the site blocks automated checks or is offline - no score is given). It is not a recommendation to buy: we recommend buying only from shops rated Trusted.
- Suspicious
- At least one warning sign, for example: a domain only weeks old with no verifiable company; a domain that lapsed and was registered again; a company number or VAT number that belongs to a business whose name is not on the site; only payment methods without buyer protection; very large discounts on a young site; no HTTPS.
- Scam
- Strong evidence: a company or VAT number on the site that does not exist, is not active or is invalid; listing by an abuse list; a young shop with no verifiable company that accepts only payment methods without buyer protection.
- Not an online shop
- The site is readable but shows no sign of selling online: no shopping cart or checkout, no products with prices, no shop platform or payment processor. A restaurant's or a blog's site is not rated as if it were a store. Strong evidence of fraud still gives Scam; warning signs are still listed. A site that may be selling anything is always rated as a shop. A shop that is online but closed (a password page, "coming soon") is not a non-shop: it is a warning sign, because fake shops often wait like this until the domain is a few weeks old.
- Website unavailable
- The domain is not registered, or it does not point to any server, so there is no website to check. This is not a scam verdict: closed shops end up here too. A domain that is on a fraud blocklist or was suspended by its registry is still rated a scam.
What we check
- Company - company and VAT numbers shown on the shop's legal pages, checked against Companies House, the Israeli Corporations Authority and EU VIES. Where Wikidata lists the shop's address as a company's official website, the report shows it for information only: it is edited by the public, so it never changes the result.
- Domain - registration date and registrar (RDAP), mail servers, hosting network.
- History - the first TLS certificate ever logged (Certificate Transparency) and the Internet Archive's captures.
- Website - HTTPS, contact/terms/returns/privacy pages, contact details, discounts. Shops that block automated visitors are read from the Internet Archive's latest copy.
- Payments - whether the shop offers methods with buyer protection.
- Reputation - abuse lists, when configured.
- Forwarding - an address that forwards to another shop (a rebrand, an acquisition) is judged by the shop it forwards to, where you would pay.
A check that could not run is listed on the report and never counts in the shop's favour.
Some of our signals are not published, so that fake shops cannot adapt to them. They never decide a verdict on their own: a warning or a scam verdict always shows at least one of the reasons listed on the report.
Correcting a result
Run the shop? If a result is wrong, make sure your legal notice shows your registered company name and number (or VAT number) and your contact details, then press "check again". If it is still wrong, ask us to correct it. Verdicts are never for sale.